Pentagon’s Controversial Move to Rename USNS Harvey Milk Undermines LGBTQ Rights

Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth has ordered the renaming of the USNS Harvey Milk, a naval oiler named after the iconic gay rights activist and Navy veteran. The decision comes amidst heightened scrutiny of Hegseth’s leadership style, which emphasizes a return to “warrior culture” while also targeting Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) initiatives within the military. This move is particularly striking given its announcement coincides with Pride Month, suggesting a deliberate action to undermine LGBTQ representation.
The ship, launched in 2021, is part of a class named after significant civil rights leaders. Renaming ships is a rare occurrence, particularly under the directive of a defense secretary. Prior renamings in recent years were typically tied to specific reviews of names linked to the Confederacy, not as a result of ideological motivations from leadership. The rationale behind Hegseth’s actions and the new name for the ship have yet to be disclosed.
Nancy Pelosi, former House Speaker, criticized the decision in strong terms, calling it a “shameful, vindictive erasure” that diminishes the contributions of those who broke barriers for equal rights. She emphasized that such actions do not bolster national security or embody American values, but rather reflect a troubling abdication of responsibility to honor the legacy of civil rights advocates like Milk. Pelosi’s remarks highlight the disconnect between Republican rhetoric on military strength and their actions undermining diversity.
Harvey Milk’s legacy as one of the first openly gay elected officials in the U.S. is significant; he was a pioneer for LGBTQ rights and faced persecution for his identity, including being forced to resign from the Navy. His efforts led to groundbreaking legislative changes protecting LGBTQ people in San Francisco. The contrasting treatment of Milk’s symbolic representation in the military underlines the current administration’s attempts to erase the values of equality and representation that have made progress in recent decades.
As military policy shifts under Hegseth’s directive, the implications for LGBTQ representation in armed forces become clearer. This renaming signals a broader trend of erasure, aligning with Republican ideology that often seeks to revert societal gains made in the name of civil rights. The challenges facing LGBTQ service members in the military today further illustrate how GOP leadership continues to reject the pillars of inclusivity established by previous administrations.
(h/t: https://www.cnn.com/2025/06/03/politics/hegseth-orders-renaming-ship-named-harvey-milk)